Welcome to the Weekend Roundup! – News & Views – 1/27/24

At the Second Vatican Council (1962-1965), the Roman Catholic church officially adopted the position of semi-Universalism, the view that all religions and even “moral” atheism are legitimate pathways to God. Pope Francis, as well as other prominent Catholic clergymen, such as bishop Robert Barron, are moving the RCC closer to full-blown Universalism by informally suggesting that hell is empty. In contrast to pope Francis, Jesus Christ stated, “And these will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life” – Matthew 25:46.

Conservative Roman Catholics are still reeling from pope Francis’ Fiducia supplicans declaration, which authorized priestly blessings for same-sex couples. Over the centuries, Catholics have boasted of their papal prerogative, claiming the absolute indefectabilty of their church because it was led by the allegedly divinely-appointed, infallible pope. That’s no longer the case. Conservative Catholic talking heads noticeably distance themselves from the papacy of progressive Francis, advising their audiences to ignore the pope and to cling to traditional Catholic doctrine. The conservative Catholic author of the first article above ponders in the affirmative whether Francis is the worst pope in history. In the second article, conservative cardinal Gerhard Müller, one of the pope’s most vocal critics, circumspectly suggests Francis is a heretic. We live in unusual times when the Roman Catholics who value the doctrines of their religion most seriously are opposed to their pope. In all of this brouhaha we see no trace of the genuine Gospel of salvation by God’s grace alone, through faith alone, in Jesus Christ alone.

Joseph Strickland was deposed as the Catholic bishop of Tyler, Texas because of his repeated criticisms of pope Francis. At the upcoming Conservative Political Action Conference’s annual Ronald Reagan Dinner in Washington, D.C on February 23rd, politically-compromised evangelicals in attendance will be enthusiastically applauding keynote speaker Strickland despite the fact that he propagates Rome’s false gospel of salvation by sacramentalism and merit. Politics idolatry causes believers to yoke with non-believers (2 Corinthians 6:14-15).

This article from a Catholic source caught my eye. The writer briefly examines a recently published book, “Why Do Protestants Convert?” [to Roman Catholicism, implied but not stated on the cover – Tom] by Brad Littlejohn and Chris Castaldo. I’ve reviewed several books from Castaldo over the years. He’s soft on the RCC, i.e., critical of many of its doctrines, but still acknowledging it as a fundamentally-Christian institution. Along the same vein, Carl Trueman, a regular contributor to the Catholic ecumenical journal, First Things, supplies the forward. Catholics make much hay out of nominal “Protestants” converting to RC-ism while evangelicals are generally embarrassed regarding those who accept Christ, leave RC-ism, and join evangelical churches. Why? Because they contradict the Rome-friendly ecumenical paradigm that’s rampant throughout evangelicalism. I’ve obtained a copy of this book and will be reviewing it down the road.

31 thoughts on “Welcome to the Weekend Roundup! – News & Views – 1/27/24

  1. RE: “He’s soft on the RCC, i.e., critical of many of its doctrines, but still acknowledging it as a fundamentally-Christian institution.” Yep! Deal with it with many “evangelicals” just 💔💔💔💔

    How can the RCC be a “fundamentally Christian institution”??? How?? And I KNOW with all my heart the Lord through His Holy Spirit showed me out of the RCC door! Why would He lead me out if there were any kind of truth to it? Why?

    Liked by 4 people

    1. I watched a “highly-respected” evangelical theologian and apologist, William Lane Craig, sit on stage with a Catholic bishop and state that while he admires the RCC as a Christian institution, he could never be a member of it because he doesn’t agree with its doctrine of justification by works. Well, an institution that teaches justification by works is not Christian! It’s not rocket science. I don’t know what goes on in these ecumenical evangelicals’ heads. Demonic deception and blindness.

      Liked by 5 people

      1. WLC is cringe on SO many levels!!! I am so frustrated how Christians can follow him blindly thinking that he is consistently dropping truth bombs against those he debates. I agree with your premise 100000%! Keep speaking the truth, Tom!

        Liked by 4 people

      2. Thanks Mandy! It’s so frustrating for me to observe an evangelical “leader” like WLC state that he could never join the RCC because of its faulty justification doctrine YET still embrace it as Christian! It’s like 2+2=5. A lot of that going around within evangelicalism.

        Liked by 3 people

      3. Goes back to brother Jim’s post on leader idolatry. It is fine to imitate leaders in the biblical sense but they are NOT on the same level as Holy Scripture and NOT God. Test all things against God’s Word.

        Liked by 4 people

      4. I went a little before and after. Wow! He mixes up, conflates and confuses a lot of things: (a) What a position on church history when he identifies what he likes about RCC by stating the RCC extending all the way back to apologists and early church fathers. (b) his mere christianity approach is no christianity. I don’t see this in the great commission; (c) one hears and sees the people laughing all the while how many are going down the broad road that leads to destruction and they are having a conversation; and then (d) there is Aquinas and Natural Theology.

        It also reminded me of the Lloyd-Jones / Stott controversy in the 60s and now we see Lloyd-Jones had a point as, sixty some odd years later, the “Church of England” is gone. We must hold fast to Holy Scripture and the true, once-for-all delivered Gospel of the Lord Jesus Christ and proclaim it everywhere to all.

        Liked by 2 people

      5. Thanks for watching, Michael, and I appreciate the good comments. Yup, WLC’s rationale is bizarre. MLJ was so right about many things. Stott and Packer are now esteemed as “great Christians.”

        Liked by 1 person

  2. I have not heard from Mr. W and I have seen him- but we have not been out as much because of the weather! Still praying for him though! 🙏🏻❤️

    Liked by 3 people

  3. It does not matter what the Vicar of Christ thinks, hell is not empty (I say that with NO pride or joy). Unless Francis repents, he will find himself there (again, I say this with no joy or pride!).

    I saw that book and thought about getting it! Perhaps I will just wait for your review!!!

    Liked by 4 people

    1. Thanks, Mandy! The Vicar of Christ is actually opposed to Christ on so many levels.

      I’m anticipating at least some degree of ecumenical compromising in the book. We shall see.

      Liked by 3 people

  4. What is so incredible is that the acceptance of Roman Catholicism as Christian is not by just one pastor/minister here and there. It’s everywhere! Wow!! What is going on? I’m looking forward to your review, Tom. Blessings…

    Liked by 3 people

    1. Thanks, Cathy. Yup, this widespread embracing of Rome is insanity. I’m curious about this book to see how much deference there is to Rome.
      BTW, I finally received my The Catholic Chronicles tract set after waiting much longer than the promised delivery date. What they sent were photo copies. Lovely. Four photocopies for $20. I need to get into that business.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. It irks me when someone takes advantage like that, especially with Christian material. But what else is new. Billy got his from eBay. There aren’t many of those tracts around, and that’s sad.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Well, at least I can read them (barely).
        Keith Green’s widow claims his thinking on RC-ism was evolving and that he was contemplating pulling the tracts from circulation before he died, which of course she eventually did. No one knows if she was telling the truth or covering for her own decision. She worked closely with Catholics with her “Americans Against Abortion” organization. I imagine there was pressure from his wife and from the Christian Contemporary Music circles Green traveled in to pull the tracts.

        Liked by 1 person

  5. 1. “We live in unusual times when the Roman Catholics who value the doctrines of their religion most seriously are opposed to their pope.”
    Its as if God’s judging Romanism…

    2. Carl Truemen needs to stop being in Bed with Roman Catholics…

    3.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for the comments!
      RE: Its as if God’s judging Romanism
      Yeah, the RCC went through the wringer (justifiably so) with the pedophile priests scandal and is now going through another crisis with Francis’ papacy. Although I’m sure Francis views it as a difficult but necessary transition from clericalism/doctrinalism to a liberal, pastoral, culturally relevant RCC. Conservative Catholics surely feel their own pope is pulling the rug out from under them.
      RE: Trueman
      It will be “interesting” to read his forward and the book itself. People like Trueman and Castaldo pay lip service to the Reformation and mildly scold the RCC for its aberrant doctrines, yet ultimately embrace it as a legitimate Christian institution.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. a.) “Conservative Catholics surely feel their own pope is pulling the rug out from under them.”
        I suspect God’s going to do more rug pulling
        b.) Truman makes me sick these days

        Liked by 1 person

      2. RE: More rug pulling
        Agreed. Conservative Catholics are hoping the next pope is a doctrinalist like JPII, but Francis has been busy stacking the deck by appointing progressive cardinals.
        RE: Trueman
        Evangelical academics who hail the Reformation while rubbing shoulders with Rome are a walking dichotomy.

        Liked by 1 person

      3. RE: Catholics who prize their church structure now have their own church structure stacked against them…irony!
        Yes, it is jaw-dropping irony. Conservative Catholics are in crisis (although they are now forced to say their “faith” is in the traditional “deposit of faith” rather than in the pope). Evangelicals “should” be paying attention.

        Liked by 1 person

  6. I look forward to your review of the book.
    I have had several Catholic students come through Christian Worldview classes the past couple of years. The average one sees a big distinction between Roman Catholics and Christians, but they have severely wonky worldviews. The ones that actually know at least some of their doctrines tend to be more ecumenical, even claiming the title Christian, and are exasperated by Francis. I’ve casually pointed out that this is a lot like 1500’s debates. A couple of those students have become good acquaintances, and a couple others have come out of RC-ism!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks, Daniel. The vast majority of Catholics hold to their church’s bottom line, that they must be good in order to possibly merit Heaven. There are certainly some Catholics who are genuinely born-again through faith in Christ alone, but the Holy Spirit is leading them through the Word to leave the RCC because it clearly and unabashedly teaches works-justification and salvation by merit.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment