The Legion of Super-Heroes in “Whispers of Doom”

It’s time once again to climb aboard our time bubble and travel to the future for another adventure with those crime-fighting heroes of the 31st Century.

The Legion of Super-Heroes in “Whispers of Doom”
Writer: Paul Levitz, Penciller: Kevin Sharpe
Adventure Comics #518, DC Comics, November 2010

4 Stars


A contingent of the newly formed Legion of Super-Heroes – Cosmic Boy, Lightning Lad, Saturn Girl, Sun Boy, and Ultra Boy – engages and subdues Zaryan’s pirates. They’re disappointed that arch-criminal Zaryan is not aboard the pirate cruiser, but obtain the coordinates of the next raid. Back in Metropolis, Phantom Girl and Superboy discuss a ghostly presence that’s been “haunting” the newly constructed Legion clubhouse. Uncomfortable with Phantom Girl’s flirtations, Superboy excuses himself to visit the Superman Museum.

Zaryan and his raiding party approach the planet Naltor, but are surprised that a combined force of Science Police and Legionnaires are awaiting them. After a brief engagement, Zaryan and the pirates realize they are overwhelmed and flee. The leader of Naltor, Beren Kah, praises young Nura Nal for her precognition, which helped thwart the raiders. Nura foresees herself as a Legionnaire (Dream Girl), but also has a disturbing vision of one of the heroes dying in a future engagement with Zaryan. Kah attempts to send a warning to the Legionnaires.

At the Superman Museum, Superboy learns his future, that he will be killed by Doomsday as an adult.* The aforementioned ghostly presence warns Superboy to immediately return to his own time. Brainiac 5 oversees the Boy of Steel’s return to 20th century Smallville via a time bubble.


The fledgling Legion picks up where it left off last issue, fighting Zaryan, but with the abrupt “out of the blue,” addition of new members Brainiac 5, Phantom Girl, Sun Boy, Superboy, and Ultra Boy. Perhaps Levitz could have provided a very brief summary of how the four additional members joined (excluding Superboy, whose recruitment was covered in Adventure #12). Who/what is this ghostly presence? Which Legionnaire will die?

*Unlike the linear and unalterable plotlines of the Silver Age, events presented as fact have zero meaning in DC’s ever-shifting universe.

10 thoughts on “The Legion of Super-Heroes in “Whispers of Doom”

  1. Wow I gotta read this! Comics! But answering your question first: Today I went to walk at the garden in the morning! NOrmally don’t do that since I normally homeschool the kids, but I did that today since my wfie and kids were seeing my wife’s sister and so I took it as a break to read a book on logic and argument for God that I been meaning to read in a while. I got a lot of reading in and lots of steps already before lunch; so I”m happy! Will be doing an apologetics interview for a youtube apologetics show today, will have that on the blog eventually

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks! Yup, Dream Girl has the ability to foresee the future. That would otherwise make her one of the most powerful Legionnaires, but the ability was always presented as somewhat sporadic.

      It will be interesting to see how Levitz “plays out” this dead Legionnaire plot-line. I’m enjoying this “young Legion” storyline, which continues for just two more issues and then it’s back to the “older” Legion storyline that I started with last July.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. This makes me wonder all kinds of metaphysical questions with comics creative team and how they conceptualiZe future foresight and wonder how the next two series will have to say about it!

        Liked by 1 person

      2. With her ability to see the future, Dream Girl should have been one of the Legion’s most powerful members, but the Silver Age creative team only used her as a very minor character.

        Liked by 1 person

      3. RE: Fatalism or philosophizing

        Yeah, the Legion’s creative teams could have explored some really strange plotlines using Dream Girl as the focus. If taken to its logical conclusion, Dream Girl’s power would have theoretically ended the need for a Legion.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s