Throwback Thursday: Opinion: Prayer in public schools

Welcome to this week’s “Throwback Thursday” installment. Today, we’re going to revisit a post that was originally published back on September 26, 2016 and has been revised.


I attended Catholic parochial grammar school in the 1960s and even though I was very young at the time, I can remember the nuns buzzing about the U.S. Supreme Court rulings banning conscripted prayer and Bible reading in public schools (Engel v. Vitale, 1962, Murray v. Curlett, 1963). I felt sorry for those poor kids in public schools for not being able to pray like me. By seventh grade, I was envying them.

The ban on school sanctioned prayer was an extremely bitter pill for evangelicals to swallow and remains a sour memory. The ban on school prayer was the first major defeat in the war to defend American “Christendom.” Some older evangelicals are still pining about it 60 years later. But that was just the beginning. Since then, most every example of government-endorsed religious expression has been challenged in the courts with no end in sight.

From our history lessons, we know the Puritan Christian immigrants to this country could not imagine anything other than the semi-theocratic form of government they imposed. Many universities got their start as church-sponsored seminaries. Mounting demand for religious freedom led to the prohibition of a state religion by the federal constitution adopted in 1793, but Christianity would remain as a major influence on federal, state, and local governments for 150 years. It was agreed from Maine to California that America was a “Christian nation.” Government-sanctioned prayer and the reliance on Judeo-Christian laws, values, and “morality” were practices and policies unquestioned. Americans had convinced themselves that God had set up a covenant relationship with the United States in the same way He had with ancient Israel; that America was THE “chosen” nation.

But things have changed in a big way in the last sixty years. The growing number of non-Christian immigrants to this country and those who rejected religion altogether began to challenge government’s sponsorship of Christianity. First to go was prayer in schools. Then Bible readings. Then such things as Christmas creches, etc., etc..

My take: Countries can’t be Christian, only people can accept Christ. We can no longer assume other citizens are Christians as was once accepted in this country. Christians can no longer impose their privileged status by claiming majority rule. That day is gone. That flag has flown. It’s obviously impossible to determine the number of genuine Christians in the U.S., but a 2014 Pew poll revealed only 25% of the population claims to be “evangelical Christian” (many would say the actual percentage is quite a bit lower), 45% are mainline Protestant or Catholic, and the remaining 30% belong to other religions or are atheists/agnostics. The government is supported by taxpayers with a wide spectrum of beliefs regarding religion and it should be completely secular. If government sanctions one religious group it must in fairness sanction all of them. If we allow monuments to the Ten Commandments on our courthouse lawns we must also allow scripture from every other religious group. On second thought, the atheists will have something to say about that. No, government must be completely secular.

I choose not to pray with non-Christians. The Lord does not want me bowing my head in a prayer led by a Muslim, Hindu, Buddhist, Catholic, etc. Why would Christian parents want their children to participate in prayers led by a Hindu or a Muslim teacher in a public school? Christians look back with longing to a simpler time when the vast majority of people in this country professed to be Christians and the church had a strong influence throughout the culture. But the probable reality was that a very large number of professing Christians hadn’t accepted Christ at all, but were just going along with the institutionalized flow imposed by American “Christendom.”

Christians, teach your children about the Lord every day in your homes. Bring them to church. But please stop complaining about prayer being banned from public schools back in 1962. Conscripted prayer in schools wasn’t a great idea then and it’s an even worse idea today. With America becoming increasingly secularized, maybe Christians can go back to spreading the Gospel as ambassadors of God and His Kingdom instead of worrying about retaining their control of the culture or “reclaiming America for Christ.”

20 thoughts on “Throwback Thursday: Opinion: Prayer in public schools

  1. Amen brother. Most of those protests for prayer are prideful assertions of ‘rights’ by folks who don’t pray at home.
    “…maybe Christians can go back to spreading the Gospel…” maybe! If they finally see that the US is, like every other country, part of the world system out of which we are called.
    Press on Tom!

    Liked by 4 people

    1. Thanks, Lisa Beth!

      RE: maybe! If they finally see that the US is, like every other country, part of the world system out of which we are called.

      Amen! But hearing the conflation of faith and politics/nationalism from their pulpits for 400 years, it’s hard for American Christians to give up the Christian nationalist paradigm.

      Liked by 4 people

    1. Thanks, David! Many American Christians have a hard time relinquishing the notion of “America, the Christian nation” but that’s not surprising given that it was preached from pulpits for 400 years.

      Liked by 3 people

    1. Thanks, Linda Lee. We don’t see faith and politics/nationalism being mixed in the New Testament other than the exhortation to pray for governmental leaders so that we can live peacefully and the Gospel can continue to be preached.

      RE: Jesus said that His kingdom is not of this world.
      That’s right. We’re just sojourners, pilgrims, and ambassadors here, not deeply invested citizens.

      Liked by 3 people

  2. I agree with you Tom… conscripted prayer not a good idea then – and an even worse idea now. This applies to any country – and there is no such thing as a “Christian” country. Individuals are Christian – and there are relatively very few around these days in any country.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Good post Tom. I fully agree. Politics and Christianity should not be mixed. The notion that America is a Christian nation has been embedded in the minds of those sitting in the pews by those preaching from the pulpits. Discernment is needed about so many things these days.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks, Cathy. When writing about or discussing this American Christian nationalism topic, the song, “God Bless America” often comes to mind. It was still quite popular when we were children. I can remember Kate Smith belting it out on television. The purpose of the song was for Americans of all religions to join together in patriotic and religious fervor and entreat “God” to bless the nation. It was an ecumenical leveler and the antithesis of Biblical Christianity.

      Liked by 1 person

    2. FYI, out of curiosity I googled Kate Smith to find out her religion. Wiki said she began attending Catholic church in 1940 and officially converted to RC-ism in 1965. Kate’s RC god isn’t my God.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. It’s crazy to think that 25 percent of professing evangelicals have many who are not truly evangelicals. Even less reason for state enforced prayers that can only cause more confusion.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. We’ve seen several surveys lately where a large percentage of so-called “evangelicals” believe all religions are legitimate pathways to God. So many claiming to be “evangelical” and “born-again” these days without any Biblical basis.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s