Young Legion: The Legion’s Origins…Again

Let’s take a frivolity break from the serious issues of the 21st Century and board our time bubble for the 31st Century for another adventure with the Legion of Super-Heroes in…

Brande Speaks
Writer: Paul Levitz, Penciller: Kevin Sharpe, Colorist: Blond aka Kevin Senft
Adventure Comics #516, DC Comics, September 2010

4 Stars

Plot

Brainiac 5 arrives in the 20th Century in a time bubble to pick up Superboy for an important meeting back at Legion headquarters in 31st Century Metropolis. The two join Chameleon Boy, Cosmic Boy, Lightning Lad and Saturn Girl at a meeting chaired by Pheebes, longtime private secretary of R.J. Brande, the recently-assassinated Legion benefactor who was one of the wealthiest individuals in the galaxy.

Via a hologram recorded before his death, Brande recounts to the gathered Legionnaires how he left the planet Durla and created a financial empire, initially by developing a method to reenergize fading stars. Desiring a way to stanch the interplanetary aggression that devastated his world, Brande envisions bringing Superman to the 31st Century as a powerful champion for peace. To that end, he funds multiple experimental time-travel projects, including one with a super-bright, young Coluian on the research team, Brainiac 5. As Brande travels across the galaxy on business, he’s notified of a breakthrough in Brainiac 5’s time-travel research and hurries back to Earth. As Brande disembarks from the starship, two disgruntled Durlans attempt to murder him, but are thwarted by three teenage passengers, Rokk Krinn from Braal (Cosmic Boy), Garth Ranzz from Winath (Lightning Lad), and Imra Ardeen from Titan (Saturn Girl), each with a unique super-power. He convinces the three to form the Legion of Super-Heroes with himself as the patron benefactor. Superboy is eventually transported to the 31st Century as Brande originally envisioned and he joins the Legion. As the hologram comes to an end, Brande instructs Pheebes to continue funding the Legion.

Comments

The Legion of Super-Heroes made its first appearance in April 1958 in Adventure Comics #247 with Cosmic Boy, Lightning Lad, and Saturn Girl visiting 1950s Smallville in a time bubble and inviting Superboy to join the Legion. Since then, Legion writers have presented several versions of the Legion’s origins, including this 2010 version.

I’ve already seen several permutations of this “Legion’s origins” narrative, so the story is…yawn…getting a bit wearisome. Brande’s identity as a disguised Durlan and the biological father of Chameleon Boy are developments presented by Legion writers following the Silver Age.

Levitz’s characterization of Brande as a grandfatherly, but bluntly-to-the-point German is humorous. The best I can say about Sharpe’s pencils is they’re passable while Blond’s colors are awesome.

It’s my contention that DC’s ongoing reboots/reincarnations/alternate-Universe permutations of the Legion have whittled away the fan base to a point that the venerable franchise is no longer sustainable as an ongoing monthly.

7 thoughts on “Young Legion: The Legion’s Origins…Again

  1. This is a much needed break from heavy news in our world of the 21st Century…ineed to read comics tonight.
    Deviant and new interpretation of origin stories sometimes takes it away from things; I like it more that they explore characters in new settings rather than change the canon of characters and team origins. Good review!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. RE: This is a much needed break from heavy news
      Thanks and very true. I’ve been watching a lot of the news out of Ukraine the last two weeks and need a little respite. The next JLA vs. LHS issue is due out tomorrow and I’m looking forward to the trip to the comic shop.

      Yeah, the constant reshuffling of the origin story is disconcerting for an old-time LSH fan like me. In Brian Michael Bendis’ version of the LSH’s origin, R.J. Brande is a woman and President of the United Planets. I take it DC’s execs and editors think they need to periodically reshuffle “history” in order to attract and retain readers, but it also alienates readers.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I too used to do a lot of browsing in my younger days in book stores, record stores, comic shops, etc., but us old guys just wanna get back home to our blanket. 👴🏻

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s