Forty Answers to “Forty Reasons I Am A Catholic”: #28

Thanks for joining me today as we continue our series examining and responding to Catholic apologist and philosopher, Peter Kreeft’s book, “Forty Reasons I Am A Catholic” (2018).


Claim #28: I am a Catholic because the Catholic Church alone in the world today is hard with courage in a world grown soft with self-indulgence, consumerist and sexual

In this very short chapter, Kreeft claims the Roman Catholic church possesses the opposite dimensions of hardness and courage in the face of moral decline and relativism, and softness and unconditional love in ministering to souls. He submits the canonized saints as shining examples of this duality. Kreeft claims the Roman church is the only institution in the world today that has the courage to oppose sin, immorality, and pragmatism, and the love to minister to people. He presents the RCC as the beacon of truth in a world increasingly confused regarding gender and sexuality.


Kreeft self-servingly presents an idealistic image of the Roman Catholic church to the reader. Even casual students of church history are aware of the corruption that has permeated the RCC in its 1500-year history. Rather than opposing moral decline and relativism, popes, prelates, and priests were often at the vanguard. The RCC was focused on the accumulation of wealth and political power throughout its history. Rather than “ministering” to souls with unconditional love, the RCC controlled its members with an iron fist, demanding absolute obedience under the threat of persecution and even death. The canonized saints? As we’ve pointed out previously, several of the canonized saints were involved in the persecution of Protestants. The notion of canonized saints itself is a blatant example of RC-ism’s spiritual deadly false gospel of salvation by sacramental pseudo-grace and merit that has entrapped billions. Courage? What about pope Pius XII? Did he have the courage to stand up to Hitler and the Holocaust?

In recent decades, the perversions and abuses of celibate priests and the hierarchical cover-up has become a scandal of tsunamic proportions. Catholic sociologist and ex-priest, Richard Sipe, determined that at least 30% of priests are homosexual. Rather than being a stalwart defender of “morality,” pope Francis pragmatically “bends the rules” in an attempt to stanch the mass exodus of disillusioned members. Church progressives, including the pope are gradually transforming the church into L**T-friendly. It’s distastefully audacious for Kreeft to boast about the RCC being the only entity “hard with courage” in a world grown soft with sexual self-indulgence in light of the twenty-two-year-old pedophile priest scandal tsunami.

Kreeft is not an idiot. He’s fully aware of the RCC’s very dark history. But in order to lure his non-Catholic readers, he presents an idealized, hagiographical, fictional image of the RCC.

It is rather God’s Word, the Bible, that is the beacon of Truth in an increasingly troubled world.

Next week: Claim #29: I am a Catholic because I need dogmatic certainty about God, and Christ, and salvation

15 thoughts on “Forty Answers to “Forty Reasons I Am A Catholic”: #28

  1. So often his claims are so out there that they fall into the category of absolute ridiculousness. Good for you for finding a response, but he is so removed from reality that if you were to sit down with him and logically discuss your responses, he would see no merit in any of them. Kreeft is adrift in a sea of delusion and make-believe.

    As usual, Tom, another stellar review on your part.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks, David! I appreciate the good comments.
      Kreeft is definitely not writing about the scandal-ridden Catholic church that myself and the general public are aware of. But there’s a certain percentage of the public that tends towards gullibility and will eat up these falsifications.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Answering your question: my day is hot and tiring so far but fun; I’m with my kids with my parents today; while being in the parkk I’m trying to read for a discipleship tonight online; I htink the heat and the late night last night isn’t a good mix! Will read this soon!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Wow for someone who is supposed to be a philosopher this Kreeft guy gives some the most simplistic airbrush version of Catholicism possible…and this book was published 2018? Nothing with the priest abuse, nothing with the weakness of Romanism compromises? If this is his basis for being a Catholic, Independent fundamentalists confronts sins far more and is thus by his standards fulfill this criteria even more so

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yup, Kreeft is presenting an extremely idealized version of Roman Catholicism. His material reminds me of the Catholic literature we received as young Catholic schoolchildren. Kreeft is trying hard to make converts and deliberately hides all of the dirty laundry.

      This highlights the difference in mindset (and spirit) between Gospel Christians and Catholics. For Gospel Christians, it’s all about Jesus and the Gospel. Criticisms of Protestant history and current foibles have zero effect upon our faith. But for Catholics, it’s ALL about the institution and they will use deception to present their institution in the best possible light. Yes, presenting the RCC as the paragon of morality and virtue is laughable in light of history and current events.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Very true. I don’t admire the guys at Catholic Answers but I think even they would be critical of Kreeft’s “cotton candy” approach in this book.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Sometimes Kreeft’s arguments are so insubstantial that it feels like religious romper room. I think the vast majority of Catholics think along the same lines as this book when it comes to theology.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s